Back to Eden Valley Guide Index
Last Updated: 1/1/2006


O.S.Sheet 91

G.R. 799 163
& 792 164




This crag will be included in the next FRCC Eastern Crags guide (due 2008)

EDEN VALLEY

Brough Scar


by
Stewart Wilson

FELL and ROCK
CLIMBING CLUB

of the
English Lake District

Brough Scar is the name given to the area of limestone escarpments high up on Musgrave Fell to the north of the A66 near Brough. These escarpments look attractive, and have often been remarked upon by climbers driving past on the way to the Lake District. On closer inspection however, the crags although reasonably continuous, lack any height in all but a few places. These areas have been developed and provide enjoyable climbing on mainly excellent rock. As with most limestone, particularly when traffic has been light, care should be taken, especially on the finishes.

The crags all face south and dry very quickly. Considering the amount of use they have had, they are quite clean. Well worth a visit.

Approaches & Access

Brough Scar is approached from the village of Brough which is reached from either the A66, or, if coming from the M6, then by the A685 from the Tebay junction.

At the west end of Brough Main Street, a road is signposted to Helbeck Quarry. Follow this road uphill for about one mile until a large quarry is reached on the left. Park here. A Public Right of Way follows the continuation cart track past the quarry entrance and uphill, after passing through a gate. After about ten minutes, a small quarry marks the junction of another track. Leave the main track and follow this left-hand track for another five minutes. The compact face of Main Buttress will be seen on the hillside above. A clump of five hawthorns half way up the slope identify the buttress.

The crag has been climbed on since 1984 and access has not been a problem. Recently however shooting interests have appeared in the form of a duck flighting pond so perhaps climbers may not be tolerated so readily. A gamekeeper is employed by the estate, and, whilst he seems to be friendly, it is up to climbers to behave in a reasonable way. It is probably best to keep a low profile and if approached, point out that you are willing to do everything to makes his job easier, except give up the right to climb.


Main Buttress

Main Buttress offers the best climbing on the Scar. The buttress presents a very compact face guarded at its base by a belt of bulges and overhangs. The rock is good and in many places provides good, natural thread runners.

Although only short, it offers steep, fingery and often strenuous climbing. Route appearances are often deceptive, looking easier and shorter than they are. A stake above the crag provides an anchor for abseil and belaying. Routes are described from left to right as one faces the rock.

The left-hand end of the buttress is scrappy above 5 or 6 metres, whilst below this it is uniformly overhanging. The main challenges here are represented by two cracked breaks.The first break has an undercut edge.

1. Boogey Down 12m E1
Start below the first break.
(6a). Gain the undercuts and pull over the bulge via a thin vertical crack.

2. Dynamo Hum 12m E4 ***
Start below an obvious thread, 3m right of Boogey Down, where the bulge eases.
(6b). Extend up and right (thread runner) across the bulge to a good hold. Climb direct to the top.

3. Arty Farty 12m E2 *
Start below the fine slim left-trending groove, one metre right of an embedded block.The groove is guarded by a bulge at head height.
(5c). Climb the groove till it meets a bulging headwall. Move right and up the corner.

4. Magic's Wand 12m E3 6a *
Artificial in that it shares some holds with the previous route. To the right of Arty Farty is a thin wall, just left of the very obvious groove line of Necromancer.
(6a). Start as for Necromancer by climbing into the groove. This is quit almost immediately in favour of a very shallow left-trending gangway in the thin wall on the left. Finish leftwards, through bulges. Excellent.

5. Necromancer 12m E1 **
Start below the most obvious grooveline 2 metres right of Arty Farty.
(5b). Climb the slim groove to a thread runner. Finish up the square-cut, hanging corner (good).

Three metres right of Necromancer, the face has a shallow, but large diamond-shaped feature at mid-height. The left-hand side of the feature is unclimbed but the right hand side provides:

6. Roxanne Shante 12m E3 **
Start at the obvious line 3 metres right of Necromancer.
(6a). Climb to the first thread, well-protected but thought-provoking. Continue past another thread runner and finish directly over a roof (care with holds!).
Chicken Variation E3
(6a). Climb the normal line to the second thread and escape rightwards to the tiny rowan tree.

To the right of the last climb, the bulges guarding the base of the crag become bigger.

7. Style of the Street 12m E4 ***
This very fine route requires strength in reserve once the initial bulge is overcome. Start at a white pillar just right of a little clean-cut corner.
(6b). Climb up to and across the roof, past a thread, to a good hold. Reach through for a jug and finish at the tiny rowan tree.

8. Cuttin' Herbie 9m E1 **
Sensational roof climbing at a modest grade. Start just right of Style of the Street below an obvious slanting handrail which cuts through the roof from left to right.
(5b). Gain a bracket-type hold (thread runner) and make a long reach for jugs above lip. "Rock-over" into a small groove to the left of the rib and finish left at a thread. Abseil off.

Other smaller buttresses have provided a number of short problems. These buttresses are further northwards on the west side of the small valley. An interesting conical hill in the valley has a steep face and may reward some exploration. The woods at the end of the valley, near Fox's Tower, contain the crags of Helbeck Wood.

Brough Scar
FIRST ASCENTS
1980s

Mentioned in the 1980 guide, no developments were forthcoming until 1984 when a small isolated band of very young, keen lads, inspired by Robin Curley paid a visit to the crag. Over the next twelve months they developed the crag. Local climbers ignored the development and most of the pioneers lost interest in climbing. The climbs were all re-ascended in 1990 by a strong team from the North-East who confirmed the quality and grades of the climbs. Its a pity the lads didn't get the encouragement they deserved at the time.